I love isekai stories! There's just something about going out armed to the teeth with blades and magic killing monsters and sleeping with exotic species that appeals to the autistic part of my brain. I just wish a truck could just hit me so I could be reincarnated in another world…

But until that happens, I guess I'll satisfy myself by consuming as many fictional isekai as I can. On this page, I will catalog all those stories that I have read or watched. The focus will obviously be on Japanese novels, manga and anime, because that's what I'm mostly consuming these days.

Legend:

Title Anime Manga LN/WN Notes
God's Blessings On This Wonderful World The story that got me to love isekai, though not my first one. I just think it is a lot of fun.
No Game No Life Probably most peoples' first isekai. I'm putting it here even though it's very different from what we think when we say isekai nowadays.
Overlord I've only watched season 1 of the anime and am currently not interested in the rest of the story.
Re:Zero - Starting Life In Another World I've only watched season 1 of the anime, though I'm planning on catching up one of these days. Either by watching the rest of the anime or reading the LN.
The Saga of Tanya the Evil
The Rising Of The Shield Hero I liked Volume 1 / episodes 1-4 but the rest I thought it's boring and uninteresting.
The World's Finest Assassin Gets Reincarnated In Another World As An Aristocrat The manga is definitely the most fun of the three versions, but I like them all.
Arifureta: From Commonplace to World's Strongest Some chuuni goodness. Nothing special about it, I just found it fun.
The Hero Is Overpowered But Overly Cautious I liked most of the jokes. The sudden change into a serious tone was a bit weird but it didn't bother me much.
Because I was Reincarnated as a Succubus, I want to squeeze out milk I was hoping for a ecchi manga about a rapist Succubus, got some lame comedy SoL.
Harem King's Adventures In Another World: The Strongest Warrior Uncle Takes Wives From All Races Has some good jokes but it would have been better if the MC was a Level 99 Rapemaster with 80 previous convictions.
Creature Girls: A Hands-On Field Journal in Another World I really like it! It's a shame that the author started going overly political with it. Like, come on man! I just wanna see some booba and fap!
Savage Hero Tits, ass and action (not the sex kind). Everything that a man needs!
Reincarnation Coliseum A mix of shounen battle and porn. Not great but it is very enjoyable.
So I'm A Spider, So What? The LN is GREAT! I LOVE it! The anime isn't necessarily bad (except maybe the second half I guess) but I didn't like how much it removed from the source material. Enough that at points the story doesn't even make any sense.
Time Stop Brave Isekai.. but with time stop. Pretty fun.
Survival in Another World with my Mistress Also known as Minecraft Isekai. It starts getting a little boring later on but it's still enjoyable.
Don't Call Me A Naked Hero In Another World A manga for ENF fans. Personally, I'm just a casual enjoyer.
The Ride-On King The official Putin isekai.
Filming Adult Videos in Another World It's a gag manga with an obvious theme. English translations are quite slow.
Harem In The Labyrinth Of Another World The beginning was kind of slow and as others have pointed out, there is no harem until the very last episode.
Kuma Kuma Kuma Bear It was cute but I'm not a big fan of slow-paced SoL stories.
Uncle From Another World
Reincarnated As A Sword
Reincarnated As A Vending Machine
Drugstore in Another World: The Slow Life of a Cheat Pharmacist
Jobless Reincarnation Not really what I'm looking for in an isekai. I dropped it when the tsundere bitch showed up.
Those Who Hunt Elves I haven't watched season 2 yet...
Now and Then, Here and There I think it would have worked better as a 3-4 episodes OVA instead of a 12 episodes series.
Isekai O Denma Dake De Ikinuku Also known as The Rising Of The Vibrator Hero. It's a meme manga, the artist clearly just wanted an excuse to draw tits, which is extremely respectable.
The Reborn Little Girl Won't Give Up

Stuff I plan on reading / watching soon(ish)

Plus whatever random shit catches my eye and decide to pick up on the side.